My Own Thoughts On The Steam Controller, Flawed, But Fun

By - | Views: 29,715
image
I honestly can’t remember the last time I was this excited about any hardware. It may only be a gamepad, but the Steam Controller is so very different it’s refreshing.

Like the idiot I am, I decided to pop along to a local GAME store for the midnight release of Fallout 4, but I must have been the only person there not getting the game. Instead I was grabbing a midnight Steam Controller since it released at the same time.

Prepare to retrain your brains and muscles, as it has a learning curve to it. Give it some time, and you might find something amazing here.

It's big, there's no getting around that, but it's not too big, here's a comparison shot for you:
image

Also, it’s not even remotely meant to replace your mouse. There’s not much point in comparing it to a mouse, as they are designed for different things. It is however, a much better gamepad for PC gaming than any other pad I’ve ever used.

It’s weird, very weird. I’m extremely comfortable with sticks on a controller, so I am way out of my comfort zone dealing with the Steam Controller’s touch pads. With that said, even with it being very different I found getting used to the pads reasonably easy. It wasn’t as much of a shock to my brain as I thought it would be, but it is a shock to my thumb. Getting precision aiming down with it is going to take a fair bit of time, which could easily put people off who aren’t too invested in what’s possible with the device. It’s pretty much a wet dream for people who like to tinker.

This is something some people are simply passing over, you can adjust things to suit your liking, and you should. Don’t just depend on official configs, or community configs. Take a leaf out of the Linux book and just tinker away!

The controller build quality is surprising, as I was expecting it to feel cheap and nasty from what I read from other sites (like IGN & PC Gamer), but I’m very happy with it. It feels similar in build quality to a Logitech F310, but it’s actually a lot nicer to hold in my hands. That’s the major bonus for me here, it’s comfy to hold and to use, even if I do have to adjust my brain to how far over the X button is. I actually like plastic designs like this, they are very light which is rather important for long gaming sessions and don’t cost the world to make or buy.

A little known fact I don’t really talk about is that I actually have a broken bone in my right hand (long story, it will never heal). It gets madly painful after typing a lot, using a mouse a lot, and especially using my F310 controller (so everything I do with this website is quite literally a pain). The pain is amplified by how damn stiff the F310 triggers still are after months of use, and something that so far after hours of use hasn’t appeared at all with the Steam Controller. Now that’s good design for you! I think the pads are actually in the perfect place, as that’s where your thumbs naturally rest, so there’s less strain to use it.

Originally, I thought it was crazy to release something like this that required normal batteries, but the more I think on it, the more it makes sense. Batteries die, batteries end up losing their charge quickly as they get older and so on. It’s actually cheaper for us to not have to replace an expensive controller just because of a crap battery. The battery location is actually fantastic, as the controller feels very balanced in your hands. As opposed to it being in the middle like the 360 controller which makes it feel heavy in the wrong place.

I haven't been able to tweak the gyro how I want just yet, so I'm not actually using it at all. Having it turned on all the time is nothing but a nuisance, but finding a button that I'm not already using in a game to enable it when held down is a problem for me personally. It doesn't help that certain config options help text is stuff like this:
image

What’s it like in games?
I’ve tried it in various games, from games designed for gamepads right up to games that need real high precision mouse aiming like Counter Strike Global Offensive.

Borderlands 2 - I have to say that Borderlands 2 was incredibly fun with the Steam Controller, and didn’t take a lot of getting used to. I did need to tweak a few settings here and there, but it doesn’t take long to get comfortable with the aiming. One thing that the Steam Controller has done for me is allow me to appreciate my character more. The melee attack is a simple press on the right pad, so it’s really easy to do as I don’t need to move any fingers away from aiming or movement. It’s the same with reloading and picking up items, simply press a paddle on the back where your fingers wrap around. It’s details like that which make me love the controller, as it actually makes some things easier to do.

Borderlands 2 does have an annoying issue though, where it will randomly show you normal keyboard controls like E instead of X. It can get confusing, and it appears quite a lot. I hope Aspyr Media or Valve (whoever the fault is with) are able to pop a fix in for it. I’ve shot off a message to Aspyr Media, so maybe we will see an update in future.

Counter Strike: Global Offensive - I honestly think it’s no way near precise enough for something as fast as Counter Strike: Global Offensive. Due to how fast you need your reaction times to be, it just isn’t a great experience. It’s not a terrible experience though, it was still fun to play. After a bit of time and tweaking I might do better, but I didn’t do any worse than I do with my mouse.

Team Fortress 2 - On the bright side, I find it hilarious playing Team Fortress 2 since you don’t need such amazing aim. It’s somewhat rekindled a love I once had for the game (and many other games actually). Bouncing about all over the place mashing the fire button to launch rockets at people from my sofa, now that’s just pure fun right there. I think I will be doing this more often.

Broforce - Works exactly the same as any other gamepad, except the added bonus that it’s wireless (the Logitech F310 isn’t), it’s more comfy to hold and it makes the game just as damn good.

Galak-Z - Like Broforce above it works exactly the same as any other gamepad, pretty damn fun game too. No issues here!

DiRT Showdown - Another one that's absolutely fine. It has gamepad support built in, so there's not really an issue. It feels good with the stick for movement, and everything functions as expected. I did try the gryo on this one to act like a steering wheel, but I can never seem to get it sensitive enough to pick up slight turns.

I will also be getting around to trying it in some strategy games, to see how good/bad it is. Once I have spent enough time testing them I may do a part 2 of this article.

Issues
It’s certainly not without flaws though, so let me get to them.

From time to time, the controller will suddenly lose the will to work properly. I always know exactly when too. Instead of the thumb-stick being precise in clicking through items in Steam Big Picture mode it will suddenly act like it’s slipping on ice and skip over items really quickly. It will start doing double button presses on a single press, and just generally act weirdly. It has never happened during actual gameplay, only when interacting with Steam Big Picture mode. Once it starts acting up though, it won’t use the configs set for games, and then it becomes a bigger issue. It’s not a signal issue either, as it happens when wired. It’s like it suddenly forgets all the configs set for it, or something like that.

The shoulder buttons feel very oddly placed, to the point that my fingers will only reach the very end of each of them, it’s a bit annoying but they are easy enough to click even at the odd angle they are positioned. I’m not sure if I’ve just been holding controllers wrong this whole time or what, but I just don’t like where the shoulder buttons are.

The ABXY buttons are a little on the small side, and the positioning will need you to adjust your brain to it. Mine still hasn’t, I keep pressing Y when I want to hit X. That will come with time though I’m sure. It’s not that I can’t reach them, just I keep pressing the wrong buttons and that’s my issue, not the Steam Controller itself.

Steam Big Picture mode is unstable, I’ve had repeated crashes when I’ve had to kill the Steam process, I’ve reported it to Valve so hopefully they will sort it out. That has soured the experience a little. I really wish it didn’t require it, as I would prefer to use the normal Steam on my desktop with it.

The right pad is too smooth for my liking, so I end up turning the haptic feedback to high on every game. My thumb just gets lost on it otherwise.

Then there's the typical "Valve Style" of leaving descriptions out for certain config options like shown in a shot above for the gyro.

As a final issue, sometimes configs you load up will be blank and look like they have nothing set for them. Some games will also claim to have zero community templates which is a lie, as I know people who did some.

Final thoughts
Will I be going back to my Logitech F310? Doubtful, once they sort the mentioned major input issue it will be nearly perfect for couch gaming.

Personally, I think Valve should have updated all of their games to have proper support for it. Especially games like TF2 where it’s quite funny to use.

It’s an excellent idea and a pretty decent gamepad. Being able to completely change the way it controls a game if I feel like it, that’s just amazing. Heck, even the little noise it makes when you turn it on sounds like something out of a retro Mario game when you collect coins, I love it.

The important thing for me is that it’s making me have more fun with my games, and making me appreciate them more.

Sadly though, the Steam Big Picture mode crashes and the gamepad suddenly forgetting how to work properly has soured the experience for me a little right now, but when it works it’s really quite fun. I'm not letting that get to me too much right now, since it’s all brand new. I just hope there's a few stability updates on their way.
image Article taken from GamingOnLinux.com.
0 Likes
We do often include affiliate links to earn us some pennies. We are currently affiliated with GOG and Humble Store. See more here.
About the author -
author picture
I am the owner of GamingOnLinux. After discovering Linux back in the days of Mandrake in 2003, I constantly came back to check on the progress of Linux until Ubuntu appeared on the scene and it helped me to really love it. You can reach me easily by emailing GamingOnLinux directly.
See more from me
The comments on this article are closed.
54 comments
Page: 1/6»
  Go to:

Segata Sanshiro 11 Nov, 2015
Pretty excited for mine. Getting someone to bring one over for me in December since they don't ship to Argentina. Pretty excited for it :)
uriil 11 Nov, 2015
When it come to Mexico I gonna grab it!!!
ricki42 11 Nov, 2015
QuoteInstead of the thumb-stick being precise in clicking through items in Steam Big Picture mode it will suddenly act like it’s slipping on ice and skip over items really quickly. It will start doing double button presses on a single press, and just generally act weirdly. It has never happened during actual gameplay, only when interacting with Steam Big Picture mode. Once it starts acting up though, it won’t use the configs set for games, and then it becomes a bigger issue. It’s not a signal issue either, as it happens when wired. It’s like it suddenly forgets all the configs set for it, or something like that.

I've had this happen, mostly starting a week ago or so (at least, I don't remember the double button presses prior to the latest firmware update). I thought I was just being incredibly clumsy with the stick and the button presses, so I'm kind of glad you have the issue too and it's a bug and not me. Have you found a reliable way to reset it to working condition?
Liam Dawe 11 Nov, 2015
Quoting: ricki42
QuoteInstead of the thumb-stick being precise in clicking through items in Steam Big Picture mode it will suddenly act like it’s slipping on ice and skip over items really quickly. It will start doing double button presses on a single press, and just generally act weirdly. It has never happened during actual gameplay, only when interacting with Steam Big Picture mode. Once it starts acting up though, it won’t use the configs set for games, and then it becomes a bigger issue. It’s not a signal issue either, as it happens when wired. It’s like it suddenly forgets all the configs set for it, or something like that.

I've had this happen, mostly starting a week ago or so (at least, I don't remember the double button presses prior to the latest firmware update). I thought I was just being incredibly clumsy with the stick and the button presses, so I'm kind of glad you have the issue too and it's a bug and not me. Have you found a reliable way to reset it to working condition?

Nope. I have found no way to reset it back to normal other than luck.
pd12 11 Nov, 2015
Waiting for it to be sold in the land down-under.

As someone who uses trackballs normally (even for precision gaming) and doesn't like the analog sticked gamepads for FPS, I'd really want to try it out! Can't wait till they ship to Australia!
ElectricPrism 11 Nov, 2015
Good read. My personal experience with CS:Go is that not even Xbox 360 Controller is capable of playing CS:GO in a way where you won't get obliterated by Keyboard/Mouse Junkies.

Also not noted in the article, I hear from my bro that the Steam Controller plays particularly well in Storm United and that the haptic feedback is his favorite feature.

I kindof see this like the Xbox 1st Gen Controller where it was a necessary iteration - I could see a v2 in maybe a year where after feedback the design is tweaked for greater perfection.

I hear they're selling these at GameStops in store? So I might grab one if I have the time after demoing my bros, I really wish they had displays at outlets like Best Buy but whatever - the whole BB staff seemed clueless that Steam Machines even launched lol. Obviously GameStop is another story.
LinuxGamesTV 11 Nov, 2015
I wish me one to my birthday ^^
I think i buy it me self: :)
kongreddgrass 11 Nov, 2015
Oh, a very long review, but it's interesting.
Today, my steam-controller arrived at home, too. I read your article after I checked the controller. This is my experience with the controllerin the first two hours: On the first view, i was thrilled about the method of construction. Especially the battery compartment. Wow, very nice idea, to build it so. Then i plug it in and was a bit confused, how to click trough BicPicture. First, i want to find out, how to operate and play Portal 2. After played a community level, i decided to do a firmware update for the controller. After waiting one minute, the controller feels so different than before. The view no longer pivots inwardly when you go with your finger on the edge. I played Portal 2 again: This was a pice of cake. Really nice pleasant to control it. :-D

But there are problems in menus, especially if you want to step trough menus with the buttons. The buttons no longer work at once. Then i have to use my keyboard. This is in the moment the only point of criticsm. Whereby in BigPicture, i have no problems to control trough the menu. I'm sure, that there are more some criticsm points, when I continue to test the Controller.

I think it was not a bad decision to buy the controller. The improvements can still be felt, sooner or later. ;-) One may well be surprised just what comes as new.
Mohandevir 11 Nov, 2015
Personnaly my rig is built on SteamOS and I don't have all the issues you're talking about. It feels much more seamless.

The only annoyance was in Dirt:Showdown, with the Gyro turned on you have to be carefull with the controller positionning or you get a non-stopping scrolling menu. Once turned off, the experience is awesome.

Edit : I must admit that I have no controller reference because I hated the dual analog stick convention. To me the Steam Controller feels really natural.


Last edited by Mohandevir on 11 November 2015 at 11:27 pm UTC
MayeulC 11 Nov, 2015
Thanks for this review :)

I've personally refrained myself multiple times from clicking on the checkout button... I think I'll wait for the next iteration or revision. Well, at least if I can resist the temptation until then ;)
While you're here, please consider supporting GamingOnLinux on:

Reward Tiers: Patreon. Plain Donations: Liberapay or PayPal.

This ensures all of our main content remains totally free for everyone with no article paywalls. We also don't have tons of adverts, there's also no tracking and we respect your privacy. Just good, fresh content. Without your continued support, we simply could not continue!

You can find even more ways to support us on this dedicated page any time. If you already are, thank you!
The comments on this article are closed.