Confused on Steam Play and Proton? Be sure to check out our guide.

Puppy Games Aren't Impressed With Linux Sales (UPDATED)

By - | Views: 44,773

It seems Puppy Games the developers behind fun games like Revenge of the Titans have expressed their concern about Linux sales.

They took to twitter to say this:

LINUX GAMERS! To date we've made just **$12,000** from Linux games in total for all time for all four of our games! This will not do!

— Puppygames (@puppygames) September 8, 2014


Linux is a small, but growing market we know that, but some developers aren't in it for fun and only see the numbers. They said in another tweet that a factor of 10 would make it more attractive.
Personally I doubt any single developer has made a figure of $120,000 (factor of 10 on their lifetime Linux sales) from a Linux game alone yet, and hell the vast majority of indie games coming out probably won't make that in their entire lifetime.

They have four games and three employees to maintain, so I can understand where they are coming from, but with a market that's still small developers shouldn't expect too much from it yet.

UPDATE

@gamingonlinux just Steam over the last 2 years. We only otherwise sell through Humble these days but that's so little money it's irrelevant

— Puppygames (@puppygames) September 8, 2014


It seems they are only counting Steam, so their original tweet seems a little baiting to get a reaction and more sales. Not a bad thing to try to get more sales, but maybe they should actively engage with the Linux community like some other developers do?
Take it with a grain of salt too, as tweets are hard to get the message across and it's probably more friendly than it seems at first glance.

They aren't counting their own Humble Weekly Bundle which actually gave them revenue from Linux gamers at a mark around $14,000 (not counting charity) which is more than Steam, so they actually made a fair bit more from Linux than they have mentioned it seems.
They confirmed in a comment later it's around the $8,000 mark. That nearly doubled the figure in their original tweet.

They were in a Humble Bundle as well which they aren't counting, and to quote someone from reddit on the matter:

QuoteI'm curious what the breakdown by platforms was from them in the Humble Bundles. Based on this site HiB2 made $361214.76 from Linux users.

Assuming that all of them gave half to charity (leaving $180607.38) and split the non-charitable potion evenly 12 way between the 5 HiB2 games, the 6 HiB games that got pulled in and the tip for Wolfire, they should have gotten $15050.


I would also be interested to know how much they say they got from that Humble Bundle. I am pretty sure they used to do direct sales at one point too, so again a fair bit they don't seem to be counting.

Puppy Games have noted they aren't about to stop supporting Linux, but they see it as unprofitable:

@shadowrabbit64 @fdgonthier we've supported Linux for 11 years, not about to stop now. Just remarking that it is incredibly unprofitable

Puppygames (@puppygames) September 9, 2014


What do you make of all this? It's interesting to see.

If you want to support them consider buying their games on Steam. Looks like they could do with some more love from Linux gamers don't you think?

Article taken from GamingOnLinux.com.
Tags: Editorial
0 Likes
We do often include affiliate links to earn us some pennies. We are currently affiliated with GOG and Humble Store. See more here.
About the author -
author picture
I am the owner of GamingOnLinux. After discovering Linux back in the days of Mandrake in 2003, I constantly came back to check on the progress of Linux until Ubuntu appeared on the scene and it helped me to really love it. You can reach me easily by emailing GamingOnLinux directly.
See more from me
The comments on this article are closed.
113 comments
Page: 1/12»
  Go to:

rustybroomhandle 8 Sep, 2014
I'm guessing they are not counting times when they were in Humble Bundles. I'm willing to bet they made a lot more than $12k from Linux users.
muntdefems 8 Sep, 2014
I'd bet most of those $12k come from a Humble Weekly Sale featuring all their games to date. I got that bundle and so I haven't felt the need to toss any more money to them.

I guess their next release will show nicer figures regarding Linux sales.
Xzyl 8 Sep, 2014
@rusty I was going to say the same thing about the bundle...

@Liam I like to think of it as trying to drum up sales by inspiring our go getter attitude and not trying to make us seem ungrateful.

@puppygames I own your games, I am sorry sales look bad. Honestly and sadly I never play them however I think I will soon and maybe if they are fun enough buy them again for a friend.
abelthorne 8 Sep, 2014
Quoting: muntdefemsI'd bet most of those $12k come from a Humble Weekly Sale featuring all their games to date. I got that bundle and so I haven't felt the need to toss any more money to them.
No, that's their point: they're apparently counting only the sales on Steam. They said that with the Humble bundles they made more.
EKRboi 8 Sep, 2014
First, this is easy for me to say because they don't make games I am interested in but.. this sounds like whining to me. They are not making money from their total sales of any of their games on all platforms as outlined by them HERE.. All I am seeing is that they are spending a bunch of time to make games that not enough people want to play on Windows, Mac or Linux... and well linux is an easy target for a temper tantrum.

The linux gaming userbase IS small... the amount of gamers who use linux and play indie games like these may be even smaller. Whining about it wont fix it... and that $12000 is only for steam.. it doesnt accound for other linux sales or people who had them before native versions and probably played them with wine. They are not breaking even WITH linux support.. they wouldn't be doing it without either.

EDIT* I also just realized that their "factor of 10" thing is simply absurd.. according their own blog post they have hardly made that much in total for some of their games.. what a joke. Also, just read their blog, not just the one post I linked.. a lot of butthurt and crying going on there. PLUS, they don't support game demos and apparently think a video showing their game working is enough to prove it will work on your machine, and they state the obvious that making demos allows people to realize they don't like your game before buying it. Sorry Puppy Games.. -1 respect. At least I'm not a sale you would have had anyways.
seven 8 Sep, 2014
i only like one of their games, so i bought it (in a humble bundle). the other three games i really cant be bothered with. revenge of the titans is the one i bought. it took about a half year until it ran properly with dual screens. if u want sales u got to make stuff people want, a unique art style alone isn't enough.
one of the four games is actually space invaders in a new graphic setting. i'm not for that (i played the original space invaders in the arcade when it came out, yeah i'm that old)

so puppy games, impress me with a good game and i will trow money at you
dude 8 Sep, 2014
  • Supporter
1. their games were never advertised well in steam. i discovered this developer after receiving a coupon for ultratron.
2. their games are very simple, porting costs were not too high with good dev skills. <10.000 is good. my opinion.

overall sales number would also be interesting.
EKRboi 8 Sep, 2014
Quoting: dudeoverall sales number would also be interesting.

see.. http://www.puppygames.net/blog/?p=1369
its a bit outdated.. but give a clear picture.
kalin 8 Sep, 2014
And how much they made from windows and mac with this stupid and ugly games for 10 euro.
If linux users are 1% their revenue from linux must be ~1% what they expect millions ?
leillo1975 8 Sep, 2014
I think that this kind of games are expensive (9.95€). Probably if they puts the base price lower , they will sell more copies. If you see games like witcher2, CivilizationV, XCOM... in special offer and see this....
I think the choice is easy
While you're here, please consider supporting GamingOnLinux on:

Reward Tiers: Patreon. Plain Donations: Liberapay or PayPal.

This ensures all of our main content remains totally free for everyone with no article paywalls. We also don't have tons of adverts, there's also no tracking and we respect your privacy. Just good, fresh content. Without your continued support, we simply could not continue!

You can find even more ways to support us on this dedicated page any time. If you already are, thank you!
The comments on this article are closed.