Quoting: pete910

Quoting: tuubiOBS already has an AMF encoder.

This is what I use, like stated before I have used va-api it's just not even close to AMF as AMF actually works reliably and good quality recording with next to zero performance hit.

I guess I read this incorrectly:

Quoting: pete910Why not include AMF too while they where at it?

I thought you meant they should include AMF in OBS. The article doesn't mention it because it's not a new feature in 30.2.

View this comment - View article - View full comments

Quoting: pete910

Quoting: tuubi

Quoting: pete910

Quoting: tuubiSucks in what way?

Slow with bad quality at a given bitrate, and more often than not just overloads and crashes.

Did you test with OBS? I know they had bugs in their VAAPI implementation causing worse quality at some point, but those should be mostly fixed in 30.x. Also Mesa improved video encode quality on AMD's VCN in Mesa 23.3 and older VCE/UVD hardware in 24.0. You might be basing your opinion on outdated information.

For me there was no real difference in speed, quality or resource usage between the APIs, testing with ffmpeg on latest stable Mesa. And that makes sense as both make use of the same encoding hardware. I pretty much only tested AV1 encoding though, and not very thoroughly. YMMV.

Quoting: pete910Still need AMD's bit though to use the hardware.

Mesa doesn't need any proprietary bits to access the video encode hardware.

Tried with mesa 24.1 and OBS 30.1.

Quoting: tuubiMesa doesn't need any proprietary bits to access the video encode hardware.

That maybe the case but why is it so bad then if using the hardware to the full extent that AMF can?

I don't know. As I said, with ffmpeg directly there was no downside to VAAPI compared to AMF for me, and we've both got RDNA3 GPUs with VCN 4.0. A quick search didn't come up with anything confirming your findings either.

And then I found this:

https://obsproject.com/wiki/AMF-HW-Encoder-Options-And-Information [External Link]

Now I'm a bit confused. Seems like OBS already has an AMF encoder. Isn't this what you were asking for? Or is it not available on Linux or something?

View this comment - View article - View full comments

Quoting: pete910

Quoting: tuubiSucks in what way?

Slow with bad quality at a given bitrate, and more often than not just overloads and crashes.

Did you test with OBS? I know they had bugs in their VAAPI implementation causing worse quality at some point, but those should be mostly fixed in 30.x. Also Mesa improved video encode quality on AMD's VCN in Mesa 23.3 and older VCE/UVD hardware in 24.0. You might be basing your opinion on outdated information.

For me there was no real difference in speed, quality or resource usage between the APIs, testing with ffmpeg on latest stable Mesa. And that makes sense as both make use of the same encoding hardware. I pretty much only tested AV1 encoding though, and not very thoroughly. YMMV.

Quoting: pete910Still need AMD's bit though to use the hardware.

Mesa doesn't need any proprietary bits to access the video encode hardware.

View this comment - View article - View full comments

Quoting: pete910Why not include AMF too while they where at it? I know I can use va-api but it sucks compared to AMF.

Sucks in what way? They're just different APIs for the same hardware.

Quoting: preludelinuxDid AMF also add support for radv as well?

It did. Stable support landed in the latest release [External Link].

View this comment - View article - View full comments

It's been near the top of my wishlist since your Steam Next Fest article last month. I hope they smash that Kickstarter goal.

View this comment - View article - View full comments

Quoting: EikeBacked it and looking forward!

Ditto and ditto.

View this comment - View article - View full comments

Quoting: ToddL

Quoting: pilkThat is a laundry list of entry methods. Didn't think it let you go that overboard with it.

This is typical Gleam stuff whenever a contest is created and you have to jump a bunch of hoops in hopes to get enough entries to win the prize. It's not worth the hassle to do it unless you're feeling lucky today.

Note that according to the terms and conditions, the giveaway is only available for permanent residents of:
- The fifty (50) states of the United States of America, the District of Columbia, and Puerto Rico.
- Canada (excluding Quebec).
- The United Kingdom (excluding the British Overseas Territories).
- Germany, France (excluding Overseas France).

View this comment - View article - View full comments

Someone really likes the screen shake effect. :grin:

View this comment - View article - View full comments

Quoting: chr

Quoting: tuubi

Quoting: Deleted_UserOn a side note: what's with this system requirements? 8 GB RAM and 16 GB of disc space for a game that is basically a text adventure with some animations?

Maybe the voice lines are stored as 24-bit, 192kHz, 7.1 channel uncompressed audio, and the static backgrounds are actually high resolution video loops.

If so, in an ideal world this game could have an HD extras pack.

Obviously I'm joking. Surely no developer would do something as pointless as that.

View this comment - View article - View full comments

Quoting: Deleted_UserOn a side note: what's with this system requirements? 8 GB RAM and 16 GB of disc space for a game that is basically a text adventure with some animations?

Maybe the voice lines are stored as 24-bit, 192kHz, 7.1 channel uncompressed audio, and the static backgrounds are actually high resolution video loops.

View this comment - View article - View full comments