Latest 30 Comments

Quoting: elmapulI bet epic or microsoft are behind so many companies suing valve, especially ms, they mhave more to lose.

Considering how it was MS behind SCO suing Novell and IBM over Linux, I see a pattern of proxy-suits here...

[Ref: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SCO_Group,_Inc._v._Novell,_Inc. & https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SCO_Group,_Inc._v._International_Business_Machines_Corp. ]

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

Quoting: pbSteam also sells soundtracks and has a built-in music player, maybe that's what they're trying to exploit?

You have definitely a point (or two, actually).

But I guess the soundtracks *are* licensed, by the producer/publisher of the soundtrack itself. Or else, the producer/publisher could not sell it in the first place!

About the music player, yes, that's a possibility. It means that every digital music player ever (including Windows Media Player, VLC, WinAMP, etc.) should license every possible song in the remote possibility it could be used to play one?

What about other stores selling videogames - dunno, Amazon, EGS, GOG, the various app stores? They should license every song in every product they sell as well?

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

Will be surprised if this doesn't get thrown out. They are trying to extort Valve.

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

There is already an xml method to add options...
https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/mesa/mesa/-/merge_requests/12135/diffs?commit_id=b9129496a295f3aef7d96540556eced25961f66a

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

While I don't understand the deep technical stuff, overall this sounds like a big win for pretty much everyone right? The developers, maintainers, gamers, etc...?

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

Did the update and lost all my games, on the main nvme partition. I was even asked to re-login. I'm currently reinstalling my Steam Games. No problem for non Steam games like my emulation setup, though.

I was wondering what to remove... Valve solved the issue! 😄

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

Quoting: Jau

Quoting: pb

Quoting: _Mars

In 2007, PRS for Music took a Scottish car servicing company to court because the employees were allegedly "listening to the radio at work, allowing the music to be 'heard by colleagues and customers'".

From the Wikipedia page. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PRS_for_Music#Legal_cases

It happened in other countries, too. My hairdresser has a plaque informing that the music is only for employees and the customers ought to abstain from listening to it. That's where it's headed...

Smart 😅
In France you pay SASEM for any public diffusion and they pay the rights owners. But you have to have a public diffusion and it's clearly defined by the law.

The Sacem is also a bunch of extortionists.

If you pay royalties directly to the rightsholders, the Sacem will still ask for its cut. And if you only broadcast royalty-free music available in the public domain or under the terms of a Creative Commons licence, then they can still ask for royalties for some goddamn reason.

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

So the consensus is, this is obviously stupid. The question is, is the relevant law in Britain just as stupid? If this were some jurisdictions I'd try for a jury trial, because juries are less practiced at accepting insane things for the sake of the law. Not sure that's an available option in Britain.

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

I bet epic or microsoft are behind so many companies suing valve, especially ms, they mhave more to lose.

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

Quoting: pb

Quoting: _Mars

In 2007, PRS for Music took a Scottish car servicing company to court because the employees were allegedly "listening to the radio at work, allowing the music to be 'heard by colleagues and customers'".

From the Wikipedia page. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PRS_for_Music#Legal_cases

It happened in other countries, too. My hairdresser has a plaque informing that the music is only for employees and the customers ought to abstain from listening to it. That's where it's headed...

Smart 😅
In France you pay SASEM for any public diffusion and they pay the rights owners. But you have to have a public diffusion and it's clearly defined by the law.

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

Quoting: Ehvis

Quoting: BloodScourgedouble-dip? 🤔

The music industry has been the front runner for double dipping for decades. And while they say it's to protect "the artists", I highly doubt that the artists would see any notable income from it.

That was a rhetorical question 😇

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

Quoting: syylkBut... That music, licensed by the game devs, is not played on Steam. It's only played in the game(s) - where it's already handsomely licensed!

Valve is not letting users listen to the music besides what's already licensed within the videogame, and the users are exposed to the IP only after purchasing the game - and its musical license(s) - and paying the due to the authors, directly or indirectly.

How that claim could have merit?

You can listen to the trailers I guess.. 😑

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

Quoting: BloodScourgedouble-dip? 🤔

The music industry has been the front runner for double dipping for decades. And while they say it's to protect "the artists", I highly doubt that the artists would see any notable income from it.

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

Valve 1vAll they're getting a ton of XP for this.

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

Quoting: syylkBut... That music, licensed by the game devs, is not played on Steam. It's only played in the game(s) - where it's already handsomely licensed!

Valve is not letting users listen to the music besides what's already licensed within the videogame, and the users are exposed to the IP only after purchasing the game - and its musical license(s) - and paying the due to the authors, directly or indirectly.

How that claim could have merit?

Steam also sells soundtracks and has a built-in music player, maybe that's what they're trying to exploit?

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

Pure greed. Plain and simple. Just a bunch of copyright trolls.

Why be paid for our music once when we can bully storefronts to be paid for the exact same effort multiple times!?

I hope Valve decimate them in this case. Sincerely.

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

So people having a license to use and distribute music, cannot actually distribute it unless the shop they're selling it with, also buys a license.

That's...rich. But it's also the UK, home of some of world's dumbest laws.

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

Quoting: _Mars

In 2007, PRS for Music took a Scottish car servicing company to court because the employees were allegedly "listening to the radio at work, allowing the music to be 'heard by colleagues and customers'".

From the Wikipedia page. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PRS_for_Music#Legal_cases

It happened in other countries, too. My hairdresser has a plaque informing that the music is only for employees and the customers ought to abstain from listening to it. That's where it's headed...

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

Did they also sue Epic, Apple and Google? Just asking.

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

But... That music, licensed by the game devs, is not played on Steam. It's only played in the game(s) - where it's already handsomely licensed!

Valve is not letting users listen to the music besides what's already licensed within the videogame, and the users are exposed to the IP only after purchasing the game - and its musical license(s) - and paying the due to the authors, directly or indirectly.

How that claim could have merit?

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

Quoting: UltraVioleti have the game on Playstation / XBox / Switch / Steam put about 100-ish hours into each platform. i love this genre but apart from this and the first game i've yet to play a better tower defence game. if anyone knows of better or just as good tower defence games i'd love to play them.

It's a different kind of TD, as you don't shape the paths, but the Kingdom Rush games are all pretty good IMHO.
They are at a reduced price on Steam right now.

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

Quoting: MayeulC

Quoting: liloventWhy aren't they sueing the owners of these games, Microsoft, Take Two and Electronic Arts?

These already paid a license. They want the store to pay a license as well.

Well, Microsoft also has several stores, one in Windows and another one on XBox where it sells other games not developed or published by them. And that without talking about GamePass or their cloud services where again you can play games from other companies.

We can also talk about Sony, Nintendo, Apple or Google and their own game stores. I doubt any of them license the songs that all the games sold through their store use.

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

So not only do games need their music licenses, but Valve as a store is supposed to have a license too.

I don't think they are. And Valve doesn't think they are, either. Obviously we'll see what the courts say. Licensing agencies like to do a shakedown on the off-chance.

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

Quoting: liloventWhy aren't they sueing the owners of these games, Microsoft, Take Two and Electronic Arts?

Also, why isn't Epic Games and GOG sued over it, as well as all of the key vendors? Are they next in line to be sued, when Valve gives in?

This is copyrights owner right to select, who they will sue. I think MS is trying to destroy Valve/Steam. Did you remember court battle with Novel against rights to Unix?

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

Copyright shit. If I have license shop with boxed games, I can sell these boxes, right?

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

UK and everything is clear :D Great law :D

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

In 2007, PRS for Music took a Scottish car servicing company to court because the employees were allegedly "listening to the radio at work, allowing the music to be 'heard by colleagues and customers'".

From the Wikipedia page. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PRS_for_Music#Legal_cases

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

This is so stupid it makes my brain hurt. I tend to keep writing that phrase around here lately, yikes. So many things going on with legal stuff and politics that warrant that response.

In this case:

Great video games rely on great soundtracks, and the songwriters and creators behind them deserve to have their contribution recognised and fairly valued.

did this caveman Dan Gopal just invalidate his entire legal proceeding with that sentence?!?!?!?!? 🤣 Yes Dan, great games do rely on great soundtracks, yes Dan, they do. Yes Dan, you should absolutely have the game developers pay licenses for that music, yes Dan. You know what I didn't see anywhere in your statement Dan? Anything about a storefront Dan. Oops you forgot something Dan.

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

My dream for a steam update one day (I am a simple person):

• it actually exits properly when I press "steam -> exit" and doesn't just sit there forever with a screen that says "steam is shutting down" or whatever, which makes me go to the task manager and force stop the mofo.


• a "download all" button for updates on the download screen

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

Quoting: liloventWhy aren't they sueing the owners of these games, Microsoft, Take Two and Electronic Arts?

These already paid a license. They want the store to pay a license as well.

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment