Quoting: Shmerl[The wishlist entry is already above 10,000 votes](https://www.gog.com/wishlist/games/to_cd_projekt_red_bring_witcher_3_and_your_other_games_to_linux_please).

Gotta wonder what % of that list already own the game - I personally do because it got bundled with my gtx970 ( that and batman - both games promised and failed to deliver Linux version /o\ )

Possibly some do, but I don't think it matters. The main thing is the interest in it. We don't have a better way to measure demand.

I still haven't beat the first Witcher game. I kept trying to move my save game over from Windows, but could never get it to be detected with the version I was running under Wine.

Yeah, even though The Witcher 3 would probably be my top, favourite game of all time - It is looking more and more likely that it will never come to Linux. At this point, I'm just waiting for the price of the game to drop substantially, and then let's say when it is down to 75% discount I might get it as a Windows game (and try to play it with WINE).

No way I'm paying even 50% discount if it is not ported to Linux. Ported to Linux - I'd pay 100% retail price.

Safe to say it's never coming to Linux.

Quoting: GuestI really wish it would. I got curious so I sent an email to biz [A] cdprojektred.com and received a reply last night. Doesn't look great to be honest.

I think it's likely time to give up with this one guys ;)

Will buy Windows version the first day it will: 1) be 12 years old; 2) have a PLATINUM rating on appdb and 3) will cost less than $0.5. (all three should be true) ^.^

Quoting: GuestYep, sorry, you better give up waiting for this one to ever come to Linux... I cant tell you the exact details due to NDA, but can say that CDProject RED are not interested in bringing Witcher 3 to Linux (or Mac) any time soon. Yes it had to do with Witcher 2, but nothing to do with VP.

Make of that what you will, believe me or not ;)

If you're just coming here to stir up trouble, don't.

Yes the community initially acted poorly to it, but your own constant comments didn't help, especially in our IRC.

Quoting: GuestNot stirring up anything.

Sure...

Quoting: GuestYes it had to do with Witcher 2, but nothing to do with VP.

I see, I guess I got the wrong impression from that comment then, thought it was going in a different direction.

I don't get it at all then, if like you say, Witcher 2 for Linux sold well, why they wouldn't be interested in continuing.

Quoting: GuestIt probably "sold well" for Linux, but didn't "sell well" by their expectations of sales figures and they ultimately concluded it was a poor investment. Pity, but not surprising i'm afraid...

Is it your guess, or they said as much? Their report to shareholders mentioned Witcher 2 for Linux as an achievement. They wouldn't do it, if it sold poorly and they lost money (by paying VP for the port). So something doesn't make sense here.

Quoting: GuestYep, sorry, you better give up waiting for this one to ever come to Linux... I cant tell you the exact details due to NDA, but can say that CDProject RED are not interested in bringing Witcher 3 to Linux (or Mac) any time soon. Yes it had to do with Witcher 2, but nothing to do with VP.

Without details, do you know that they are not interested in TW3 for Linux, or you assume that based on the fact that they didn't ask VP to make it? Thing is, CDPR never said they cancelled their plans. Why would they pretend to be still interested in it, if they decided not to do it at all?

Quoting: GuestI really wish it would. I got curious so I sent an email to biz [A] cdprojektred.com and received a reply last night. Doesn't look great to be honest.

Can you post their response please? I'll add it to the timeline here.

Quoting: GuestUltimately, if it's the motivation WINE needs to implement working Direct3D 10/11 support then i'd say Linux gaming stands to gain.

I agree. But still CDPR appear like breaking their promises, and basically trying to hide that fact, without admitting that they did it.

Quoting: GuestThey are not breaking any promise. The "Witcher 3 coming to SteamOS" thing was a marketing mistake on Valve's part. That's already been well established.

Well established? I didn't see anyone admitting such mistake, or CDPR refuting that ad. See here also for their explicit statements which basically confirmed it. So since they never refuted or announced that such plans were cancelled, they either still have them, or they broke their promise. I don't see any good resolution of this situation for them, given their complete silence on this matter at present.

About MacOS I can understand, I don't think it's a worthy target for TW3 indeed (no newest OpenGL support, weak hardware where it runs and etc.). But about Linux, I still don't get why they were first interested and then decided not to do it. Your assumption about bad sales of TW2 doesn't really sound convincing. See their shareholders report about it.

I can only assume, their management somehow got into the mentality of legacy publishers, who usually don't grok Linux, and simply stick to mass market approach. As some developers who left CDPR hinted, they aren't "true rebels" anymore (for those unfamiliar, CDPR used to pride themselves as "rebels", who don't do things like legacy publishers).

Ugh, I hate when people post that it was a "mistake". A "mistake" that happened twice? And was confirmed by CDPR in e-mails. And Valve customer service would also confirm if you managed to contact them at the time?

It was not a mistake, however it's likely either taking longer than expected or was quietly canceled. But the lack of proper good communication sucks, and no one needs to make excuses for large corporations like CD Projekt.

Quoting: MblackwellUgh, I hate when people post that it was a "mistake". A "mistake" that happened twice?

With two different banners no less. One in the old red style and one in the new white style. Which makes stand by my earlier assessment. They simply expected VP to be able to do the same thing they did with TW2 and be done with it. It just wasn't that easy.

It may actually still happen that way when both the eON tech is mature enough to handle TW3 and the average hardware is fast enough to compensate for the loss in performance that it gives.

Until then, TW3 will just be a nice benchmark to see how Wine DX11 evolves.

Yeah, two subsequent banners (a year apart) exclude any possibility of it being a mistake or something not sanctioned by CDPR.

Quoting: GuestSure, here it is:
...
I'm hoping but I'm not holding my breath.

Thanks. What date was it on, was it on May 3rd?

Quoting: Guest

Quoting: ShmerlThanks. What date was it on, was it on May 3rd?

May 4th

I updated the timeline: https://www.gamingonlinux.com/wiki/The_Witcher_3_Linux_port

This is very insightful:

View video on youtube.com

It can probably explain highly erratic and failed release of The Witcher 3 for Linux.