Quoting: tuubi

Quoting: pete910

Quoting: tuubiSucks in what way?

Slow with bad quality at a given bitrate, and more often than not just overloads and crashes.

Did you test with OBS? I know they had bugs in their VAAPI implementation causing worse quality at some point, but those should be mostly fixed in 30.x. Also Mesa improved video encode quality on AMD's VCN in Mesa 23.3 and older VCE/UVD hardware in 24.0. You might be basing your opinion on outdated information.

For me there was no real difference in speed, quality or resource usage between the APIs, testing with ffmpeg on latest stable Mesa. And that makes sense as both make use of the same encoding hardware. I pretty much only tested AV1 encoding though, and not very thoroughly. YMMV.

Quoting: pete910Still need AMD's bit though to use the hardware.

Mesa doesn't need any proprietary bits to access the video encode hardware.

Tried with mesa 24.1 and OBS 30.1.

Quoting: tuubiMesa doesn't need any proprietary bits to access the video encode hardware.

That maybe the case but why is it so bad then if using the hardware to the full extent that AMF can?

View this comment - View article - View full comments

Quoting: Shmerl

Quoting: pete910Still need AMD's bit though to use the hardware.

If it was as simple as that nvenc,AMF ect wouldn't be needed for any graphics card.

Given that AMF has RADV support now I would have thought it would be a no brainer to add by default to OBS from now on.

Not according to AMD developers. AMF used to rely on Vulkan-like functionality plugging into hardware's ioctl, because Vulkan video was still work in progress. But now Vulkan spec and drivers have that through Vulkan API, so AMF now uses Vulkan proper, not hardware directly. So basically, you don't need to use AMF if you want to use same Vulkan video functions.

So yes, I'd say OBS and anyone else doesn't need AMF at all, as long as they know / want to use Vulkan. The only reason to support AMF according to AMD developers are some applications that already use it and can't move to Vulkan for whatever reason (like no one is developing them). And OBS isn't such case clearly, so it would be a complete waste of effort for them to add AMF support. Same goes for ffmpeg. They should focus on Vulkan video.

Is va-api using this technique of hardware encode? If so it needs some serious work to match AMF

Will vulkan vid encode also do opengl based apps ?

View this comment - View article - View full comments

Quoting: tuubiSucks in what way?

Slow with bad quality at a given bitrate, and more often than not just overloads and crashes.

Quoting: ShmerlAMF uses Vulkan video. So better ask, why not include Vulkan video directly to OBS?

Still need AMD's bit though to use the hardware.

If it was as simple as that nvenc,AMF ect wouldn't be needed for any graphics card.

Given that AMF has RADV support now I would have thought it would be a no brainer to add by default to OBS from now on.

View this comment - View article - View full comments

Why not include AMF too while they where at it? I know I can use va-api but it sucks compared to AMF.

View this comment - View article - View full comments

Fudge, Now I feel old :huh:

View this comment - View article - View full comments

Showing just how much Microsoft's attitude has changed with Xbox Game Studios

Probably because they've realised game pass is not sustainable :wink:

View this comment - View article - View full comments

Quoting: Purple Library GuyI feel like I should play Stellaris on this.

Was going to ask if this was sponsored by Pardox :grin:

View this comment - View article - View full comments

ooo, This looks tasty!

Have looked in the past for a decent fan conttrol software for us linux folk. Never heard of this before.

Installed it.

Shame it don't follow the naming as in the sensor.conf file but thats a minor thing.

View this comment - View article - View full comments

Quoting: dpanter

Quoting: ssj17vegetaAs a long-standing (K)Ubuntu user for the last 15 years, I was wondering, is Manjaro the "rolling release distro with the power of Arch minus the hassle of reading tons of documentation" or not ?

No. Manjaro is rotten garbage, avoid at all costs.
If you want Arch, use Arch.

Complete and utter bullshit !

View this comment - View article - View full comments

Quoting: Murray

Quoting: pete910:huh:
erm, SC works fine for me!

Is this a fix for certain configurations then ?

Working for me too! I wonder if it's to prevent the launcher from forgetting your username and password... that would be great.

That realy p**** me off too, though to be fair not done it in the last month +

View this comment - View article - View full comments